Top 7 Safest Neighborhoods to Live in NYC with the Best quality of life – 2024

Despite the reputation of big cities across the country being deemed unsafe, NYC does have safe neighborhoods. A combination of the five boroughs in NYC, each representing their own culture, way of life, food, cost of living, and businesses, creates a unique living experience. There are things to know when moving to New York State, such as that living here is safe, and that some neighborhoods are safer than others.

Are you looking for a neighborhood in NYC where you could feel comfortable and secure? MovingWaldo has got you covered! The Top 7 Safest Neighborhoods in NYC with the Best Quality of Life as of 2024 are listed below!

Methodology

Our ranking methodology is based on a careful analysis of crime rates derived from the Borough and Precinct Crime Statistics provided by the NYPD. To ensure accuracy, we calculated the average number of various crimes per 1000 people, including Murders, Rapes, Robberies, Felonious Assaults, Burglaries, Grand Larcenies, and Grand Larceny Autos.

The crime data utilized pertains to the year 2022. The selection of this particular year is due to the fact that agencies, on a voluntary basis, submit data encompassing the entirety of the previous year. Subsequently, there exists an administrative period required for the meticulous organization and dissemination of the data on the web platform.

The “Best quality of life” aspect is measured based on feedback from real people who have moved to this area in our database or real people from trusted online forums. More specifically, we generally look for positive feedback on job opportunities, quality of education, quality of healthcare, feeling of safety, public transportation, environment (cleanliness), as well as availability of recreational facilities and parks.

Widgets Magazine

Ad

Safest Neighborhoods to Live in NYC

Featured in this article

Ad

1. Canarsie

Canarsie, Brooklyn - City View
  • Population: 96,286 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 8.70 crimes per 1000 people (69th precinct)

Canarsie stands out for having access to natural beauty. The community lies along Jamaica Bay’s coast, providing beautiful waterfront views and possibilities for outdoor activities.

With stunning views of the sea and the Manhattan skyline, the Canarsie Pier is a well-liked location for fishing and waterfront strolls. It is a popular hangout for locals and one of the highlights of the neighborhood.

In terms of safety, it’s important to highlight that Canarsie has a low crime rate compared to other Brooklyn areas.

The neighborhood has a reported crime rate of 8.70 crimes per 1,000 people, making it our top pick for safest neighborhood to live in NYC. Canarsie High School, one of New York City’s historic educational institutions.

City data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Canarsie ,Brooklyn, NYC

2. Rego Park

Rego Park, Queens - Tall Buildings
  • Population: 61,618 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 14.67 crimes per 1000 people (112th precinct)

Rego Park, part of the 112th precinct, has a low crime rate of 14.67 crimes per 1000 people, ensuring a safe and peaceful living environment for its residents.

The neighborhood offers quality education with schools like P.S. The Lynn Gross Discovery School and Rego Park School. With Flushing Meadows-Corona Park nearby, residents have access to extensive green spaces and recreational facilities. 

Rego Park’s diverse range of restaurants serves cuisines from around the world, delighting food enthusiasts. Positive reviews on online forums like Reddit praise Rego Park for its abundance of restaurants and easy commute, making it an ideal and secure place to call home.

City data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Rego Park, Queens, NYC

3. Forest Hills

Forest Hills, Queens - Street Sign
  • Population: 46,646 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 19.39 crimes per 1000 people (112th precinct)

Forest Hills, part of the 112th precinct with a low crime rate of 19.39 crimes per 1000 people, is a safe neighborhood in NYC.

Residents enjoy a vibrant atmosphere with Austin Street as the main commercial hub, offering entertainment options, and Forest Hills High School for education.

Forest Park, one of Queens’ largest parks, provides abundant green spaces for outdoor activities. The neighborhood creates a welcoming community with numerous schools and churches.

Its proximity to major airports like LaGuardia and JFK adds to the convenience of travel for residents and young professionals. Forest Hills offers the best of both worlds, combining the benefits of NYC living with a serene and family-friendly environment.

City data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Forest Hills, Queens, NYC

4. Morningside Heights

  • Population:  35,262 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 22.71 crimes per 1000 people (26th precinct)

Morningside Heights, part of the 26th precinct, has a low crime rate of 22.71 crimes per 1000 people, making it one of NYC’s safest neighborhoods to live. 

It is home to prestigious institutions like Columbia University, Barnard College, Teachers College, the Manhattan School of Music, and St. John the Divine, giving it the nickname “Academic Acropolis of Manhattan.” 

Residents appreciate its walkable environment and easy access to nearby Cathedral Parkway. This sought-after neighborhood’s convenient location, close to work and Manhattan, is highlighted in positive reviews on online forums like Reddit.

City data (2020), NYPD (2022) & SCUP

Morningside Heights, Manhattan, NYC

5. Huguenot

Huguenot - Staten Island Ferry
  • Population: 16,981 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 30.62 crimes per 1000 people (123rd precinct)

Huguenot, part of the 123rd precinct with a low crime rate of 30.62 crimes per 1000 people, offers a peaceful suburban living environment, making it an appealing choice for those seeking a quieter lifestyle away from the bustling city.

Residents enjoy access to several parks, including the expansive Conference House Park, ideal for outdoor activities, picnics, and sports. 

The neighborhood embraces diversity, fostering a harmonious and welcoming atmosphere for all, as noted in reviews from real people on platforms like Reddit.

With nearby schools like P.S. Henry M. Boehm Elementary School, P.S. 069, Daniel D. Tompkins Elementary School, and P.S. 032: The Gifford School, Huguenot, ensures a family-friendly and secure environment for residents of all ages.

City data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Huguenot, Staten Island, NYC

6. Carroll Gardens

2. Caroll Gardens - The 8 Best Neighborhoods in Brooklyn in 2022
  • Population: 14,367 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 39.32 crimes per 1000 people (76th precinct)

Carroll Gardens, part of the 76th precinct, with a low crime rate of 39.32 crimes per 1000 people, a combination of property crimes and violent crimes, stands as our pick of NYC’s safest neighborhood.

It is known for its beautiful Carroll Park, which provides a green space for sports and relaxation. Families appreciate schools like the International School of Brooklyn for ensuring quality education.

Real people on online forums praise the neighborhood for its stately brownstones, charming churches, and authentic Italian bakeries, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

City Data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Carroll Gardens ,Brooklyn, NYC

7. Annadale

Annadale, Staten Island - Staten Island Ferry Terminal
  • Population: 10,202 (2020)
  • Crime rate: 50.90 crimes per 1000 people (123rd precinct)

Annadale, part of the 123rd precinct with a low crime rate of 50.90 crimes per 1000 people, is one of the safest neighborhoods to live in NYC.

Its laid-back and tranquil atmosphere sets it apart from other parts of the city. Proximity to recreational spots provides opportunities for water sports, camping, and fishing, offering a welcome escape from city life while remaining well-connected to NYC.

Blue Heron Park adds to the appeal, reflecting Staten Island’s unique lifestyle. Reviews on online forums like Reddit confirm that Annadale is an excellent place to raise a family, assuring residents of safety day or night.

City data (2020) & NYPD (2022)

Annadale, Staten Island, NYC

Featured in this article

Conclusion

When moving, one of the most important considerations to take into account is safety. Many additional factors are negotiable, but safety and property protection cannot be ignored. Our selection of the top 7 safest neighborhoods in NYC with the best quality of life in 2024 might help you decide where you’ll live. Choosing a suitable neighborhood takes time, so go over this list carefully before making your final decision.

Are you planning to move soon? Learn about the Best NYC movers!

Ad

Share this article on social media

Ann Nacario

The author

Meet Ann – our head writer with a knack for making moving and city living a breeze. From the many details of moving to picking the perfect moving company, she’s your guide. Ann has a friendly yet detailed approach to ensure your move goes off without a hitch. When she’s not writing about relocation, it will always be on her mind, but you’ll catch her spending time with her three furry friends.

Relevant for your move

Find a mover

Easily compare multiple quotes

Organize your move

Guided through a checklist

Internet packages

Get up to speed on the new deals

Address change

Update your address in a few clicks

Join the network

Become a trusted vendor in your service area

For agents and brokers

MovingWaldo is a one-stop-shop that simplifies tackling moving tasks

What is MovingWaldo?

We guide millions of families through each step of their moving process, helping them save time and money, and making sure nothing gets left behind.

Trouver un déménageur

Comparez plusieurs devis

Organisez votre déménagement

Guidé à travers une checklist

Changement d’adresse

Mettez à jour votre adresse en quelques clics

Forfaits internet

Soyez au courant des nouvelles offres internet à domicile

Rejoignez le réseau

Devenez un fournisseur de confiance pour desservir votre région

Professionnels de l’immobilier

Prolongez la relation avec vos clients grâce à votre propre plateforme de déménagement personnalisé

Qu'est-ce que MovingWaldo ?

MovingWaldo est un guichet unique qui simplifie la planification du déménagement

Get our printable change of address checklist directly in your inbox